Who's my guy... Ethier or Lind?? WHIR

[woowoo crew]

I'm looking to trade Nady and Mark Teahen for a slight upgrade in my OF. I offered them for Nelson Cruz already. I doubt he'll go for it, even though Teahen is a starter and has been hitting well.

Would you go after Lind, who has been super hot and has had lots of at bats or Andre Ethier, who has struggled a bit and been moved to 6th in the line-up?? OR, do you think there is a better option I should target?
Stats are: H/AB R H 1B 2B 3B HR RBI SB AVG OPS NSB CYC SLAM. I know, that's a ton!!

THANKS! My team is below. Trust me, I know I could use some more pitchers, but there is NO one available, and I've offered trade after trade for one, to no avail.

C: Iannetta
1B: Morneau
2B: Kinsler
3B: Chris Davis
SS: Stephen Drew
IF: Jose Lopez
OF: Braun, Chris Young, Nady, Daniel Murphy
UTIL: Francouer
Bench: Blalock, Teahen, Guillen (D/L), Schafer, Brandon Inge
SP: Haren, Harden, Verlander
RP: Broxton, Wilson, Corpas
P: Jurrjens, Slowey
Bench: Cueto

[Slow Pitch]

Despite being a Blue Jay fan I would go for Either.

[SpecialFNK]

Lind is off to a hot start, but i like the Dodgers lineup alot better.
Lind probually has a higher ceiling for HR. he could have around 25+ where as Ethier will probually be around 20+.
Ethier is the better hitter and i would count on him having a better AVG.
Lind K more at career 20.0 % compared to Ethier at career 17.0%.
Ethier has a higher walk rate at career 9.5% compared to Lind at 5.1 %.
neither one are going to do much stealing bases.
i would like Ethier alot more if he was hitting infront of Manny like he was last season after Manny arrived. even 4/5/6 he still has better players around him than Lind does in Toronto.
Lind will probually have slightly better power numbers, but overall i like better total numbers from Ethier and hes probually better for the categories you mentioned.

[Singles]

I like Ethier here as well. Better line up and overall better hitter. If he moved up in the order he would have even more value.


viewtopic.php?t=378554

[djxskillz]

ethier over lind easy.

[Guzman24]

Yup. Have to agree with the majority. Ethier for sure.

Mine: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=378570

[TheGhost]

Go for Eithier by a long shot. Highly doubt you'll be able to trade for Cruz and only give up Tehan and some other scrub. Good luck!!

[Millhouse]

Thanks for mine. I think you have your answer, but...ethier.