Positional Rankings

• Tweet

• Tweet

Several experienced members of the Cafe decided to disclose their personal rankings to the world, and also compile them to get the averages of those rankings. Just over a month later, we’ve managed to pull this report together for you.

To compile these rankings, each player was assigned a rank by each ranker; the lower this score compared with other players, the better. By combining these lists, we can see both individual preferences and the overall consensus among the rankers.

Average rank indicates the average of the scores assigned to a player by each person. For this calculation, if there is a blank spot in an individual’s personal rankings, it’s treated as a non-rank and excluded from the average. For example: David Ortiz has a couple of blank spots due to him not being ranked as a first baseman because in some leagues he only qualifies at the utility position – however, those blanks are dropped for the average rank calculation. Each ranker’s list can be seen in the columns at the right.

Please note that this is a tool for draft preparation; it will not be updated throughout the season. Note also that standard 5×5 scoring was assumed for these rankings.

We hope you enjoy the rankings! Hopefully our fantasy baseball skills are better than our organizational prowess and the rankings are worth the wait.

Catchers	Avg Rank	BP	CHR	DAU	JD	MUG	PP	RM	SIM	STY	TLL	BK
Mauer, Joe	1.09	2	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1
Martinez, Victor	2.45	1	2	2	3	3	3	3	2	3	2	3
McCann, Brian	2.45	3	3	3	2	2	2	2	3	2	3	2
Piazza, Mike	5.91	6	4	10	4	4	4	4	7	4	13	5
Hernandez, Ramon	6.27	4	10	4	7	7	6	5	6	6	6	8
Johjima, Kenji	6.45	7	9	7	6	9	5	8	4	8	4	4
Martin, Russell	7.27	9	5	5	5	6	9	10	8	9	8	6
Rodriguez, Ivan	7.73	10	7	6	8	10	7	9	5	7	5	11
Posada, Jorge	7.73	8	6	9	9	5	8	6	10	10	7	7
Barrett, Michael	8.00	5	8	8	10	8	10	7	9	5	9	9
Pierzynski, AJ	12.73	13	11	11	11	17	13	14	12	12	16	10
Varitek, Jason	12.91	11	15	12	14	14	11	15	11	11	14	14
LoDuca, Paul	15.00	18	12	20	15	15	12	20	14	13	11	15
Laird, Gerald	15.78	15	14	17	16		20	11		19	10	20
Estrada, Johnny	16.20	12	19	19		12	14	18	13	14	24	17
Iannetta, Chris	16.25	16	16	14		16	17	13	17		21
Kendall, Jason	16.67			22	13		15		15	15	20
Molina, Bengie	17.13	19	17	13	18	13		16	18		23
Ross, David	17.20		13	24	12	18	16	19	16	16	19	19
Napoli, Mike	17.57	17	20	15	20	11	25				15
Olivo, Miguel	17.80			16	17		19		19		18
Paulino, Ronny	17.86			21	19	20	18	17		18	12
Montero, Miguel	18.25			18				12			27	16
Bard, Josh	19.67	14	18	23			21			20	22
Barajas, Rod	20.50					19			20		25	18
Zaun, Greg	21.00	20		25			22				17
Doumit, Ryan	22.50									17	28
Lopez, Javy	25.00						24				26

 

First Basemen	Avg Rank	B P	C H R	D A U	J D	M U G	P P	R M	S I M	S T Y	T L L	B K
Pujols, Albert	1.00	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1
Ortiz, David	2.33	2	2		2	2		2	2	4	3	2
Howard, Ryan	2.73	3	3	2	3	3	2	4	3	2	2	3
Berkman, Lance	4.36	5	4	3	5	4	4	5	4	6	4	4
Hafner, Travis	4.63	4	5		4	5		3		5	6	5
Teixeira, Mark	5.55	6	6	4	6	6	3	6	5	8	5	6
Lee, Derrek	6.82	9	7	5	8	7	6	9	6	3	7	8
Morneau, Justin	7.45	8	8	8	7	8	5	7	8	7	9	7
Konerko, Paul	8.09	7	9	6	9	9	7	8	7	10	8	9
Delgado, Carlos	11.00	10	11	7	10	11	8	12	10	16	16	10
Thome, Jim	11.33	12	10		11	10		11	9	9	19	11
Fielder, Prince	12.82	11	12	13	15	12	9	17	11	17	12	12
Sexson, Richie	13.00	14	13	11	12	18	12	13	12	14	11	13
Giambi, Jason	14.36	16	17	9	13	13	10	14	13	15	23	15
Helton, Todd	14.60	15	16	14	17	16		16	14	11	10	17
LaRoche, Adam	15.73	13	15	10	16	14	15	18	15	21	18	18
Swisher, Nick	15.73	19	14	12	14	20	11	19	16	13	21	14
Gonzalez, Adrian	16.82	17	18	15	19	19	13	20	17	18	13	16
Thomas, Frank	18.83		21		18	17				23	15	19
Overbay, Lyle	19.45	20	20	17	20	22	16	21	20	19	14	25
Garciaparra, Nomar	19.89	21	22	19	21	15	14		19	24		24
Jackson, Conor	20.60	18		16	22	25	17	23	18	25	22	20
Cuddyer, Michael	21.40		19			24		25		22	17
Jacobs, Mike	22.17	22		18			18		24		25	26
Youkilis, Kevin	22.29	25	24	21	23		21				20	22
Shealy, Ryan	22.57		23	20	25		20		23		24	23
Hillenbrand, Shea	23.33	24					19				27
Johnson, Nick	23.71		25		24			22	25	20	29	21
Johnson, Dan	25.33					21	24				31
Sweeney, Mike	25.50	23									28
Casey, Sean	26.50					23					30

 

Second Basemen	Avg Rank	B P	C H R	D A U	J D	M U G	P P	R M	S I M	S T Y	T L L	B K
Utley, Chase	1.00	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1
Figgins, Chone	2.50	2	4		2	3		3	2	2	2
Roberts, Brian	3.18	3	2	2	4	8	3	2	3	3	3	2
Cano, Robinson	4.18	7	3	3	3	2	2	7	4	8	4	3
Weeks, Rickie	6.36	4	5	5	6	6	4	4	6	12	12	6
Lugo, Julio	8.00	5	14	9	5	9	5	11	11	4	6	9
Uggla, Dan	8.36	11	8	4	8	5	6	10	5	6	14	15
Barfield, Josh	9.36	12	7	6	7	12	10	8	9	5	17	10
Kinsler, Ian	9.60	9	13	13	11	7	13	5		13	7	5
Kendrick, Howie	9.82	13	9	12	9	14	8	18	7	9	5	4
Kent, Jeff	10.00	8	6	15	13	4	7	6	10	11	22	8
Iguchi, Tadahito	10.91	6	11	8	12	11	9	15	13	15	9	11
Phillips, Brandon	11.18	10	12	7	10	19	11	12	12	7	16	7
Giles, Marcus	14.20		10	14	15	13	15	13	15	17	18	12
Durham, Ray	15.00	17	15	10	14	18	17	17		14	11	17
Sanchez, Freddy	15.09	15	18	18	17	10	12	22	16	16	8	14
Freel, Ryan	15.17	18	19			15		14		10	15
Burke, Chris	16.80			16	18		21	9			20
Cantu, Jorge	17.22	16	17	17		16		19	14	18	19	19
Lopez, Jose	18.00	14	20	22			18		18		21	13
Hudson, Orlando	18.09	20	16	20	16	20	24	21	17	19	10	16
Polanco, Placido	19.17						19	16	19	20	23	18
Castillo, Luis	19.67	19		21	19		23	23			13
Pedroia, Dustin	21.25			23		17		21			24
Biggio, Craig	21.25						25	20	20			20
Wigginton, Ty	21.40			19	20		22	21			25
DeRosa, Mark	22.00						20	24

 

Shortstops	Avg Rank	B P	C H R	D A U	J D	M U G	P P	R M	S I M	S T Y	T L L	B K
Reyes, Jose	1.00	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1
Jeter, Derek	2.73	5	2	2	3	2	3	3	3	3	2	2
Tejada, Miguel	3.18	3	3	4	4	3	2	4	2	2	5	3
Rollins, Jimmy	3.27	2	4	3	2	4	4	2	4	4	3	4
Young, Michael	5.64	4	6	6	6	5	6	5	6	6	6	6
Ramirez, Hanley	5.64	6	5	5	5	8	5	9	5	5	4	5
Furcal, Rafael	7.27	7	7	7	7	7	7	7	8	9	7	7
Guillen, Carlos	8.64	8	9	9	9	6	8	10	9	8	9	10
Hall, Bill	8.82	11	8	8	10	10	9	8	7	10	8	8
Glaus, Troy	9.17	9			8	9		6		11	12
Lopez, Felipe	11.18	10	10	10	11	16	10	12	12	7	10	15
Lugo, Julio	12.00	12	12	11	12	12		13	13	12	11	12
Renteria, Edgar	12.73	14	11	14	13	11	12	17	10	14	13	11
Drew, Stephen	13.36	15	13	13	16	20	11	11	11	13	15	9
Cabrera, Orlando	14.70	13	14	16	14	13		16	14	17	17	13
Sanchez, Freddy	15.45	16	18	17	15	15	13	18	15	15	14	14
Peralta, Jhonny	16.18	19	15	12	17	14	17	15	16	18	16	19
Greene, Khalil	17.63		19	21			14	14	18	16	22	17
Tulowitzki, Troy	18.00		16	19			18				21	16
Aurilia, Rich	18.50			15	20		20			19
Vizquel, Omar	19.00	18	17	20	18		23	20	17		18	20
Bartlett, Jason	19.25			23	19		16				19
Betancourt, Yuniesky	19.75	17		24		18					20
Crosby, Bobby	20.14	20	20	22			15		20		26	18
Uribe, Juan	21.00			18			24	19			23
Eckstein, David	21.67					19	21				25
Barmes, Clint	22.00					17	22				27
Pedroia, Dustin	22.00									20	24

 

Third Basemen	Avg Rank	B P	C H R	D A U	J D	M U G	P P	R M	S I M	S T Y	T L L	B K
Rodriguez, Alex	1.09	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	2	1
Cabrera, Miguel	1.91	2	2	2	2	2	2	2	2	2	1	2
Wright, David	3.00	3	3	3	3	3	3	3	3	3	3	3
Ramirez, Aramis	4.18	4	4	4	4	4	4	4	4	5	5	4
Atkins, Garrett	4.91	5	5	5	5	5	5	5	6	4	4	5
Figgins, Chone	7.45	7	6	10	6	7	9	8	10	6	7	6
Zimmerman, Ryan	8.18	6	10	8	10	8	7	10	9	8	6	8
Rolen, Scott	8.55	9	7	11	7	9	6	7	5	11	13	9
Glaus, Troy	8.82	11	8	6	8	6	10	6	8	10	14	10
Jones, Chipper	9.18	8	11	7	9	10	8	12	7	7	15	7
Hall, Bill	10.71	13	9		12	15		9		9	8
Crede, Joe	14.10	10	16	13	14	13	13	15	15	15		17
Beltre, Adrian	14.10	16	12	9	15	16	20		12	19	9	13
Chavez, Eric	14.27	14	15	21	11	11	11	11	16	17	19	11
Tracy, Chad	14.33	15		16	20		14	16	11	13	12	12
Lugo, Julio	14.57	17	18	11	13	20				12	11
Teahen, Mark	15.44	20		14	18		15	13	13	14	16	16
Gordon, Alex	16.00		19	20	16		17				10	14
Encarnacion, Edwin	16.30	18	13	15		12	18	18	17	20	17	15
Blalock, Hank	17.50	12	17	19	19	18	12	20	14		25	19
Ensberg, Morgan	17.56		14	12	17	14	22	14	18		24	23
Freel, Ryan	17.67					17				18	18
Huff, Aubrey	18.67			18			16	17		16	23	22
Mora, Melvin	19.43	19	20	17			23		19		20	18
Lowell, Mike	20.33					19	21					21
Upton, BJ	21.00						24	19	20		22	20
Youkilis, Kevin	21.50			22							21
Hillenbrand, Shea	27.00										27

 

Outfielders	Avg Rank	B P	C H R	D A U	J D	M U G	P P	R M	S I M	S T Y	T L L	B K
Soriano, Alfonso	1.00	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1
Crawford, Carl	2.73	4	3	3	2	4	2	2	3	2	2	3
Beltran, Carlos	3.55	3	2	7	3	3	4	3	2	4	6	2
Guerrero, Vladimir	3.73	2	4	2	5	2	3	8	4	3	3	5
Berkman, Lance	5.18	5	5	4	6	5	6	4	5	6	7	4
Holliday, Matt	6.82	7	8	6	8	7	10	6	7	5	4	7
Ramirez, Manny	6.82	6	10	5	7	6	5	9	6	7	8	6
Sizemore, Grady	8.18	8	6	13	4	11	7	7	11	10	5	8
Bay, Jason	8.82	10	9	8	9	8	8	5	9	11	11	9
Lee, Carlos	9.64	9	7	9	10	10	9	10	8	8	12	14
Suzuki, Ichiro	12.09	12	14	10	14	13	12	11	13	12	10	12
Wells, Vernon	12.09	13	13	16	12	9	13	14	10	13	9	11
Abreu, Bobby	12.45	11	12	11	13	12	11	15	12	14	13	13
Jones, Andruw	12.64	15	11	14	11	14	14	13	14	9	14	10
Dye, Jermaine	15.73	17	15	12	15	15	17	17	16	17	16	16
Damon, Johnny	17.64	18	17	19	16	18	18	16	19	23	15	15
Figgins, Chone	18.50	16	20	22	17	25		19	17	15	17	17
Sheffield, Gary	19.27	14	18	23	19	21	19	20	15	19	26	18
Dunn, Adam	19.60	23	19	17	18	20		12	18	29	21	19
Matsui, Hideki	20.00	19	16	15	23	16	15	18	21	22	33	22
Baldelli, Rocco	23.73	25	25	18	21	23	28	21	24	24	31	21
Pierre, Juan	24.36	21	31	21	20	24	21	48	20	16	19	27
Hunter, Torii	25.09	30	26	20	27	26	24	29	23	18	22	31
Young, Delmon	26.36	24	27	35	24	31	20	36	27	26	20	20
Francoeur, Jeff	26.45	26	23	24	26	19	22	45	29	25	27	25
Ibanez, Raul	27.82	22	28	25	33	27	30	23	36	28	24	30
Rios, Alex	28.00	20	21	36	22	17	27	32	22	42	45	24
Ordonez, Magglio	28.27	27	22	30	29	22	26	30	28	20	51	26
Swisher, Nick	28.91	29	24	32	25	41	25	25	26	21	47	23
Patterson, Corey	30.82	34	29	31	28	28	29	28	25	27	46	34
Drew, JD	32.73	31	32	29	30	36	23	27	30	30	60	32
Cuddyer, Michael	34.82	28	33	34	40	44	41	26	42	33	34	28
Crisp, Coco	34.91	38	36	37	35	33	35	41	32	34	23	40
Burrell, Pat	35.30	36	35	27	36		31	31	33	35	37	52
Markakis, Nick	36.73	35	30	42	31	30	45	55	35	44	28	29
Cameron, Mike	38.09	50	46	26	32	40	40	40	41	31	35	38
Bonds, Barry	38.40	32	34	28	37		32	38	31	50	66	36
Teahen, Mark	38.50		47		34						32	41
Young, Chris	39.44	56	38	48	54		37	34	37		18	33
Hawpe, Brad	39.73	33	44	46	44	29	36	24	49	32	63	37
Upton, BJ	42.00							35			49
Quentin, Carlos	42.22	42	37	52	38			56	39	45	36	35
Willingham, Josh	43.40	39	39	51	41	32	39		53	54	41	45
Byrnes, Eric	43.60	40	41	43	39	39		57	44	52	42	39
Taveras, Willy	43.75	51	52		43	38		39	45		25	57
Kearns, Austin	45.56	47	51	40	50		34	33	47		55	53
Freel, Ryan	45.89	49			51	37	49	42	43	39	43	60
Granderson, Curtis	46.00	54	42	59	45			49	38	46	39	42
Giles, Brian	47.45	60	48	58	52	45	33	52	48	53	30	43
Alou, Moises	47.71	45	43	33	47	51	50				65
Huff, Aubrey	48.00	43	49	47	48	53		37	57	37	50	59
Matthews, Gary	48.00		53	45		59	42		46	40	48	51
Jones, Jacque	48.40		54	38	42	56	44	47	59	36	58	50
Edmonds, Jim	48.45	53	40	39	53	50	47	60	34	51	62	44
Roberts, Dave	49.50	46	58		57	52	48	54	56	47	29	48
Podsednik, Scott	49.50	37			59	34	38				64	65
Rowand, Aaron	49.63	44		55	55		46		51	43	57	46
Griffey, Ken	49.78	55		41	56		43	43	40	41	80	49
Bradley, Milton	50.38	41		57		47	52	44		48	52	62
Youkilis, Kevin	50.67							51		57	44
Winn, Randy	51.00			56		35			58	55	38	64
Hart, Corey	53.00		50	54					50			58
Monroe, Craig	53.17		60	44	49				54		56	56
Gomes, Jonny	53.40	59	45			42		46			75
Duffy, Chris	54.50					55			60		40	63
Hermida, Jeremy	55.00	57	59	53		54		53		49	68	47
Blake, Casey	55.00									38	72
DeJesus, David	55.25	58	56				54				53
Lofton, Kenny	56.00				58		51				54	61
Ethier, Andre	57.00		57	50			56		52	58	71	55
Scott, Luke	57.20	48	55		46						83	54
Duncan, Chris	57.29	52		49			55	58	55	56	76
Green, Shawn	59.00					46	58				73
Wilkerson, Brad	59.50							50			69
Dellucci, David	59.50					49					70
Gonzalez, Luis	60.50					43					78
Gibbons, Jay	65.00					48					82
Guillen, Jose	66.00					58				59	81
Encarnacion, Juan	67.00									60	74
Burke, Chris	67.00										67
Floyd, Cliff	69.00							59			79
Wilson, Preston	71.50					57					86
Mench, Kevin	72.50					60					85
Jenkins, Geoff	77.00										77

 

Starting Pitchers	Avg Rank	B P	C H R	D A U	J D	M U G	P P	R M	S I M	S T Y	T L L	B K
Santana, Johan	1.00	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1	1
Carpenter, Chris	2.09	2	2	2	2	2	2	2	2	2	3	2
Oswalt, Roy	3.82	3	3	3	3	4	3	4	4	5	6	4
Peavy, Jake	4.55	5	5	4	4	5	5	3	6	6	2	5
Halladay, Roy	4.91	4	4	5	5	3	4	7	3	3	13	3
Zambrano, Carlos	6.91	7	6	9	6	7	6	5	7	7	10	6
Webb, Brandon	7.27	6	7	15	7	6	8	10	5	4	5	7
Sheets, Ben	7.55	8	8	6	10	10	7	6	8	8	4	8
Smoltz, John	11.55	9	9	7	8	11	15	9	9	24	15	11
Sabathia, CC	12.82	10	10	19	9	8	27	8	15	10	7	18
Lackey, John	13.91	11	14	26	11	9	12	18	12	14	14	12
Kazmir, Scott	14.50	22	11	8	15		13	19	16	11	21	9
Myers, Brett	16.64	17	21	14	17	14	18	11	17	12	16	26
Schilling, Curt	16.64	24	12	12	21	17	25	15	10	21	11	15
Matsuzaka, Daisuke	17.00	18	18	27	13	24	11	16	19	15	12	14
Hernandez, Felix	17.27	20	17	11	12	27	14	23	21	18	17	10
Bonderman, Jeremy	17.30	15	15	13	18		20	17	11	32	9	23
Schmidt, Jason	19.00	16	26	22	23	12	10	13	18	16	20	33
Harden, Rich	20.64	13	29	24	28	15	9	12	22	28	26	21
Young, Chris	20.64	14	22	20	20	22	19	28	26	29	8	19
Hamels, Cole	20.91	25	20	10	22	26	16	20	27	30	18	16
Harang, Aaron	21.27	21	13	25	16	19	23	24	20	20	25	28
Haren, Dan	21.91	23	19	21	14	13	29	14	25	39	22	22
Weaver, Jered	22.89	19	25	16	40	23	28		23	19		13
Cain, Matt	23.73	12	16	23	19	31	30	21	31	38	23	17
Willis, Dontrelle	25.30	32	24	39	25	18		32	13	17	33	20
Zito, Barry	29.70	28	27		37	20	26	34	38	9	41	37
Mussina, Mike	30.10	36	31	17	24		35	35	32	37	27	27
Johnson, Randy	30.45	30	35	18	31	35	32	33	14	40	29	38
Burnett, AJ	31.55	33	42	31	27	41	21	27	33	27	30	35
Verlander, Justin	31.64	26	28	49	35	25	22	31	35	22	45	30
Bedard, Erik	31.91	31	23	30	30	34	37	26	34	43	32	31
Arroyo, Bronson	33.55	44	32	34	41	21	24	25	40	23	36	49
Beckett, Josh	33.73	43	37	35	38	30	17	36	37	13	46	39
Capuano, Chris	34.73	27	30	38	29	16	57	29	28	50	42	36
Papelbon, Jonathan	34.89	42	38	29	33		49		30	31	37	25
Bush, Dave	35.45	35	34	32	39	39	34	30	36	44	24	43
Pettitte, Andy	36.20	38	41	37	26		42	46	29	25	49	29
Escobar, Kelvim	36.25	40	39	36	45	45		22			19	44
Hill, Rich	37.63	41	33	44	32	46			42		31	32
Wainwright, Adam	38.50	45							39	26	44
Patterson, John	38.80	37	36	28	36	48	38		24	46	55	40
Santana, Ervin	39.45	34	44	43	43	28	40	39	54	34	51	24
Olsen, Scott	42.22	29	40	47	42	37	54			54	43	34
Snell, Ian	44.00		54					38			40
Lowe, Derek	45.00	50	46	58	44	32	41	44	44	41	48	47
Garcia, Freddy	45.13	57		42	47	42		42		42	39	50
Johnson, Josh	45.78	48	43	50	50	29			41	48	52	51
Prior, Mark	47.44	39			34	60	33	49	43	47	77	45
Penny, Brad	47.70	56		41	52	54	36	45	46	33	50	64
Wang, Chien-Ming	48.25	53			53	33		43	56	35	71	42
James, Chuck	48.38	46	45	54	46	57			45		53	41
Vazquez, Javier	48.91	55	50	33	56	36	47	48	55	60	35	63
Millwood, Kevin	49.20	51		57	48	47	31	54	57	36	58	53
Clemens, Roger	49.33		51	40	60		44	47			54
Maddux, Greg	50.38		47	55	49	52	55	59			38	48
Reyes, Anthony	50.71	49	55	53	51				52		28	67
Sanchez, Anibal	50.89	52		59	55	38	46		50	59	47	52
Lilly, Ted	51.00				57	51		51			34	62
Contreras, Jose	51.40	47	58	56	54		39	37	49	52	65	57
Garza, Matt	52.50										59	46
Robertson, Nate	52.75						51	41			63	56
Lee, Cliff	53.38		49	48		44		40	58	45	68	75
Glavine, Tom	53.50		56		58		52		48
Igawa, Kei	56.67			46					47			77
Lowry, Noah	57.00					40		56			75
Jennings, Jason	57.67							50			62	61
Heilman, Aaron	58.00							60			56
Bonser, Boof	58.20		60	45						56	60	70
Garland, Jon	58.25						43	57		57	76
Hudson, Tim	58.33					53	50	55	59		74	59
Buerhle, Mark	58.38		52	51		50	58	53	53		81	69
Sowers, Jeremy	59.80	54	53	52							72	68
Martinez, Pedro	59.83	60	59			49	56				57	78
Colon, Bartolo	60.43	58	57				60	52		53	83	60
Cabrera, Daniel	60.60				59	58				49	64	73
Westbrook, Jake	60.67					56			60		66
Francis, Jeff	60.67		48								80	54
Rogers, Kenny	61.00					43					85	55
Padilla, Vicente	62.25						59			55	69	66
Davis, Doug	62.50					55			51		70	74
Billingsley, Chad	63.67	59									67	65
Blanton, Joe	65.33					59				58	79
McCarthy, Brandon	69.00									51	84	72
Wood, Kerry	73.00										73
Hernandez, Livan	74.00							58			88	76
Pelfrey, Mike	74.50										78	71
Weaver, Jeff	82.00										82
Perez, Odalis	86.00										86
Mulder, Mark	87.00										87
Liriano, Francisco	89.00										89

 

Relief Pitchers	Avg Rank	B P	C H R	D A U	J D	M U G	P P	R M	S I M	S T Y	T L L	B K
Rodriguez, Francisco	1.45	2	2	2	1	1	1	1	1	1	2	2
Nathan, Joe	1.64	1	1	1	2	2	3	2	2	2	1	1
Ryan, BJ	3.55	3	3	5	3	3	5	3	3	4	4	3
Rivera, Mariano	4.09	5	5	4	4	4	2	5	4	3	5	4
Wagner, Billy	4.27	4	4	3	5	5	4	4	5	5	3	5
Street, Huston	6.82	6	8	6	8	6	6	8	6	6	6	9
Hoffman, Trevor	7.55	8	6	7	6	7	9	7	7	8	11	7
Putz, JJ	7.73	7	7	10	7	11	7	6	9	7	8	6
Cordero, Chad	10.40	9	9	8	10	16		10	12	9	9	12
Jenks, Bobby	11.09	10	13	12	11	8	8	12	15	12	13	8
Saito, Takashi	12.27	15	16	9	9	10	13	15	8	11	14	15
Cordero, Francisco	12.27	12	10	13	13	14	11	9	18	14	10	11
Lidge, Brad	12.73	13	12	11	15	13	16	11	10	18	7	14
Ray, Chris	12.82	11	11	16	12	12	12	13	14	10	17	13
Gordon, Tom	14.64	17	18	15	16	9	14	14	17	13	12	16
Gagne, Eric	16.00	18	15	14	14	20	10	22	11	19	16	17
Fuentes, Brian	16.09	14	14	18	17	17	23	16	13	20	15	10
Wickman, Bob	19.64	19	19	20	18	15	22	18	16	25	26	18
Isringhausen, Jason	20.09	16	21	21	19	21	15	21	21	15	32	19
Valverde, Jose	20.10	21	17	17	21	23	17	19	20		18	28
Jones, Todd	21.36	20	20	19	22	19	20	20	24	21	29	21
Zumaya, Joel	21.56		23	25	25		21	17	23	16	22	22
Torres, Salomon	22.63	22	22	22	20				27	22	23	23
Dotel, Octavio	23.50		26	26	23	18	19		25		31	20
Papelbon, Jonathan	23.50				26						21
Broxton, Jonathan	23.80		24		26			24			20	25
Shields, Scot	24.14		29	24	26				30	17	19	24
Benitez, Armando	24.71		28		26	22	18		19		34	26
Borowski, Joe	25.56	23	25	23	26	25		23	22		33	30
Soriano, Rafael	26.75				26					24	25	32
Tankersley, Taylor	27.00	25			24						30	29
Otsuka, Akinori	27.40		30		26					23	24	34
Dempster, Ryan	27.63		27		26	24	24	25	26		36	33
Linebrink, Scott	27.75			27	26						27	31
Weathers, David	28.00	24			26				28		35	27
Gonzalez, Mike	28.50				26		25				28	35
Liriano, Francisco	31.50				26						37

 

Legend BP=Big Pimpin CHR=chris8 DAU=Daullaz JD=j_d_mcnugent MUG=Mugrila PP=pokerplaya RM=RynMan SIM=Simulacrum STY=EugeneStyles TLL=The Loveable Losers BK=bigken117

Special thanks to those listed in the table above, and everyone else who donated their time to make this ranking list possible. Thanks again guys!

 
The Loveable Losers (known as Bob in the parlance of those not addicted to fantasy sports) is a computer programmer and numbers junky from New Carlisle, Ohio.
 

Rate this article: (77 votes, average: 3.66 out of 5)  Loading ... Questions or comments for Bob? Post them in the Cafe Forums! Want to write for the Cafe? Check out the Cafe's Pencil & Paper section!