Cafe Home
Fantasy Football
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
Fantasy Cafe Wiki
In this draft, twelve forum regulars attempted to create a winning roster not only for 2004, but for the following seasons as well. As with any mock draft, the individual drafters’ preferences and team needs obviously play a role in their respective choices, and a player’s rank might therefore vary from what you might expect from a cheat sheet compiled outside of actual draft conditions. For complete details and discussion of the draft in progress, please visit the Keeper Mock Draft Forum.
| Pick # | Player | Round | Team |
| 1. | Alex Rodriguez – SS, Tex | 1 | josh |
| 2. | Albert Pujols – 1B/OF, StL | 1 | grammy |
| 3. | Vladimir Guerrero – OF, Mon | 1 | nsulham |
| 4. | Carlos Beltran – OF, KC | 1 | rotodog |
| 5. | Alfonso Soriano – 2B, NYA | 1 | jivedude |
| 6. | Todd Helton – 1B, Col | 1 | pkarr |
| 7. | Carlos Delgado – 1B, Tor | 1 | Justise |
| 8. | Mark Prior – SP, ChN | 1 | mikcou |
| 9. | Roy Halladay – SP, Tor | 1 | abomb |
| 10. | Nomar Garciaparra – SS, Bos | 1 | ukjohn |
| 11. | Jason Giambi – 1B, NYA | 1 | chinch |
| 12. | Jeff Kent – 2B, Hou | 1 | kentx |
| 13. | Barry Bonds – OF, SF | 2 | kentx |
| 14. | Pedro Martinez – SP, Bos | 2 | chinch |
| 15. | Magglio Ordonez – OF, ChA | 2 | ukjohn |
| 16. | Vernon Wells – OF, Tor | 2 | abomb |
| 17. | Edgar Renteria – SS, StL | 2 | mikcou |
| 18. | Bret Boone – 2B, Sea | 2 | Justise |
| 19. | Manny Ramirez – OF, Bos | 2 | pkarr |
| 20. | Jim Thome – 1B, Phi | 2 | jivedude |
| 21. | Gary Sheffield – OF, Atl | 2 | rotodog |
| 22. | Sammy Sosa – OF, ChN | 2 | nsulham |
| 23. | Eric Gagne – RP, LA | 2 | grammy |
| 24. | Kerry Wood – SP, ChN | 2 | josh |
| 25. | Josh Beckett – SP, Fla | 3 | josh |
| 26. | Juan Pierre – OF, Fla | 3 | grammy |
| 27. | Javier Vazquez – SP, Mon | 3 | nsulham |
| 28. | Tim Hudson – SP, Oak | 3 | rotodog |
| 29. | Curt Schilling – SP, Ari | 3 | jivedude |
| 30. | Miguel Tejada – SS, Oak | 3 | pkarr |
| 31. | Scott Rolen – 3B, StL | 3 | Justise |
| 32. | Lance Berkman – OF, Hou | 3 | mikcou |
| 33. | Preston Wilson – OF, Col | 3 | abomb |
| 34. | Carlos Lee – OF, ChA | 3 | ukjohn |
| 35. | Derek Jeter – SS, NYA | 3 | chinch |
| 36. | Mark Mulder – SP, Oak | 3 | kentx |
| 37. | Eric Chavez – 3B, Oak | 4 | kentx |
| 38. | Jason Schmidt – SP, SF | 4 | chinch |
| 39. | Randy Johnson – SP, Ari | 4 | ukjohn |
| 40. | Mike Mussina – SP, NYA | 4 | abomb |
| 41. | Mike Lowell – 3B, Fla | 4 | mikcou |
| 42. | Richie Sexson – 1B, Mil | 4 | Justise |
| 43. | Barry Zito – SP, Oak | 4 | pkarr |
| 44. | Johan Santana – SP, Min | 4 | jivedude |
| 45. | Aubrey Huff – 1B/OF, TB | 4 | rotodog |
| 46. | Jeff Bagwell – 1B, Hou | 4 | nsulham |
| 47. | Garret Anderson – OF, Ana | 4 | grammy |
| 48. | Carl Crawford – OF, TB | 4 | josh |
| 49. | Roy Oswalt – SP, Hou | 5 | josh |
| 50. | Miguel Cabrera – 3B/OF, Fla | 5 | grammy |
| 51. | Jorge Posada – C, NYA | 5 | nsulham |
| 52. | Kevin Millwood – SP, Phi | 5 | rotodog |
| 53. | Ichiro – OF, Sea | 5 | jivedude |
| 54. | Bobby Abreu – OF, Phi | 5 | pkarr |
| 55. | Rafael Furcal – SS, Atl | 5 | Justise |
| 56. | Andruw Jones – OF, Atl | 5 | mikcou |
| 57. | Ivan Rodriguez – C, Fla | 5 | abomb |
| 58. | Brian Giles – OF, SD | 5 | ukjohn |
| 59. | Mike Piazza – C, NYM | 5 | chinch |
| 60. | Hank Blalock – 3B, Tex | 5 | kentx |
| 61. | Mark Teixeira – 1B/3B/OF, Tex | 6 | kentx |
| 62. | Luis Gonzalez – OF, Ari | 6 | chinch |
| 63. | Kevin Brown – SP, LA | 6 | ukjohn |
| 64. | Luis Castillo – 2B, Fla | 6 | abomb |
| 65. | Javy Lopez – C, Atl | 6 | mikcou |
| 66. | John Smoltz – RP, Atl | 6 | Justise |
| 67. | Chipper Jones – OF, Atl | 6 | pkarr |
| 68. | Jim Edmonds – OF, StL | 6 | jivedude |
| 69. | Marcus Giles – 2B, Atl | 6 | rotodog |
| 70. | Bartolo Colon – SP, ChA | 6 | nsulham |
| 71. | Jason Kendall – C, Pit | 6 | grammy |
| 72. | Troy Glaus – 3B, Ana | 6 | josh |
| 73. | Billy Wagner – RP, Phi | 7 | josh |
| 74. | Brandon Webb – SP, Ari | 7 | grammy |
| 75. | Eric Hinske – 3B, Tor | 7 | nsulham |
| 76. | Orlando Cabrera – SS, Mon | 7 | rotodog |
| 77. | Shawn Green – OF, LA | 7 | jivedude |
| 78. | Keith Foulke – RP, Oak | 7 | pkarr |
| 79. | Matt Morris – SP, StL | 7 | Justise |
| 80. | Andy Pettitte – SP, NYA | 7 | mikcou |
| 81. | Derrek Lee – 1B, Fla | 7 | abomb |
| 82. | Jose Vidro – 2B, Mon | 7 | ukjohn |
| 83. | Mariano Rivera – RP, NYA | 7 | chinch |
| 84. | Eddie Guardardo – RP, Min | 7 | kentx |
| 85. | Scott Posednik – OF, Mil | 8 | kentx |
| 86. | Aaron Boone – 2B/3B, NYA | 8 | chinch |
| 87. | Hideo Nomo – SP, LA | 8 | ukjohn |
| 88. | Randy Wolf – SP, Phi | 8 | abomb |
| 89. | Michael Young – 2B, Tex | 8 | mikcou |
| 90. | Russ Ortiz – SP, Atl | 8 | Justise |
| 91. | Carlos Zambrano, SP, ChN | 8 | pkarr |
| 92. | Greg Maddux – SP, Atl | 8 | jivedude |
| 93. | Wade Miller – SP, Hou | 8 | rotodog |
| 94. | Angel Berroa – SS, KC | 8 | nsulham |
| 95. | Mark Loretta – 2B, SD | 8 | grammy |
| 96. | Frank Thomas – 1B, ChA | 8 | josh |
| 97. | Octavio Dotel – RP, Hou | 9 | josh |
| 98. | Jake Peavy – SP, SD | 9 | grammy |
| 99. | Rich Harden – SP, Oak | 9 | nsulham |
| 100. | Troy Percival – RP, Ana | 9 | rotodog |
| 101. | Jose Reyes – SS, NYN | 9 | jivedude |
| 102. | AJ Burnett – SP, Fla | 9 | pkarr |
| 103. | Corey Patterson – OF, ChN | 9 | Justise |
| 104. | Tim Worrell – RP, SF | 9 | mikcou |
| 105. | Jason Isringhausen – RP, StL | 9 | abomb |
| 106. | Phil Nevin – 1B/OF, SD | 9 | ukjohn |
| 107. | Torii Hunter – OF, Min | 9 | chinch |
| 108. | Alex Cintron – 3B/SS, Ari | 9 | kentx |
| 109. | Hideki Matsui – OF, NYA | 10 | kentx |
| 110. | Ryan Klesko – 1B, SD | 10 | chinch |
| 111. | Aramis Ramirez – 3B, Pit | 10 | ukjohn |
| 112. | Rafael Palmeiro – 1B, Tex | 10 | abomb |
| 113. | Esteban Loaiza – SP, ChA | 10 | mikcou |
| 114. | Joel Pineiro – SP, Sea | 10 | Justise |
| 115. | Bill Mueller – 3B, Bos | 10 | pkarr |
| 116. | Matt Clement – SP, ChN | 10 | jivedude |
| 117. | Larry Walker – OF, Col | 10 | rotodog |
| 118. | Todd Walker – 2B, Bos | 10 | nsulham |
| 119. | Richard Hidalgo – OF, Hou | 10 | grammy |
| 120. | Rocco Baldelli – OF, TB | 10 | josh |
| 121. | Kazuo Matsui – SS, NYN | 11 | josh |
| 122. | David Ortiz – 1B, Bos | 11 | grammy |
| 123. | Robb Nen – RP, SF | 11 | nsulham |
| 124. | Mike Sweeney – 1B, KC | 11 | rotodog |
| 125. | Sean Burroughs – 3B, SD | 11 | jivedude |
| 126. | Livan Hernandez – SP, Mon | 11 | pkarr |
| 127. | Austin Kearns – OF, Cin | 11 | Justise |
| 128. | Kevin Millar – 1B/OF, Bos | 11 | mikcou |
| 129. | Morgan Ensberg – 3B, Hou | 11 | abomb |
| 130. | Jamie Moyer – SP, Sea | 11 | ukjohn |
| 131. | CC Sabathia – SP, Cle | 11 | chinch |
| 132. | Woody Williams – SP, StL | 11 | kentx |
| 133. | Ugueth Urbina – RP, Fla | 12 | kentx |
| 134. | Francisco Cordero – RP, Tex | 12 | chinch |
| 135. | Kazuhiro Sasaki – RP, Sea | 12 | ukjohn |
| 136. | Derek Lowe – SP, Bos | 12 | abomb |
| 137. | Sidney Ponson – SP, SF | 12 | mikcou |
| 138. | Matt Mantei – RP, Ari | 12 | Justise |
| 139. | Joe Borowski – RP, ChN | 12 | pkarr |
| 140. | Mark Buerhle – SP, ChA | 12 | jivedude |
| 141. | Johnny Damon – OF, Bos | 12 | rotodog |
| 142. | Bernie Williams – OF, NYA | 12 | nsulham |
| 143. | Jay Gibbons – OF, Bal | 12 | grammy |
| 144. | Ramon Hernandez – C, Oak | 12 | josh |
| 145. | Pat Burrell – OF, Phi | 13 | josh |
| 146. | Trot Nixon – OF, Bos | 13 | grammy |
| 147. | Vicente Padilla – SP, Phi | 13 | nsulham |
| 148. | Jorge Julio – RP, Bal | 13 | rotodog |
| 149. | Jason Varitek – C, Bos | 13 | jivedude |
| 150. | Mike Lieberthal – C, Phi | 13 | pkarr |
| 151. | Geoff Jenkins – OF, Mil | 13 | Justise |
| 152. | Rich Aurilla – SS, SF | 13 | mikcou |
| 153. | Danny Kolb – RP, Mil | 13 | abomb |
| 154. | Jimmy Rollins – SS, Phi | 13 | ukjohn |
| 155. | Jay Payton – OF, Col | 13 | chinch |
| 156. | Jose Guillen – OF, Oak | 13 | kentx |
| 157. | Mike Hampton – SP, Atl | 14 | kentx |
| 158. | Ray Durham – 2B, SF | 14 | chinch |
| 159. | Nick Johnson – 1B, NYA | 14 | ukjohn |
| 160. | Bobby Crosby – SS, Oak | 14 | abomb |
| 161. | Reggie Sanders – OF, Pit | 14 | mikcou |
| 162. | Juan Gonzalez – OF, Tex | 14 | Justise |
| 163. | Placido Polanco – 2B/3B, Phi | 14 | pkarr |
| 164. | Trevor Hoffman – RP, SD | 14 | jivedude |
| 165. | Juan Encarnacion – OF, Fla | 14 | rotodog |
| 166. | Danny Graves – RP, Cin | 14 | nsulham |
| 167. | Bob Wickman – RP, Cle | 14 | grammy |
| 168. | Adam Dunn – 1B/OF, Cin | 14 | josh |
| 169. | Dontrelle Willis – SP, Fla | 15 | josh |
| 170. | Jerome Williams – SP, SF | 15 | grammy |
| 171. | Dmitri Young – 3B/OF | 15 | nsulham |
| 172. | Jose Contreras – SP, NYA | 15 | rotodog |
| 173. | Paul Konerko – 1B, ChA | 15 | jivedude |
| 174. | Brad Penny – SP, Fla | 15 | pkarr |
| 175. | Freddy Garcia – SP, Sea | 15 | Justise |
| 176. | Carl Everett – OF, ChA | 15 | mikcou |
| 177. | Raul Ibanez – 1B/OF, Sea | 15 | abomb |
| 178. | AJ Pierzynski – C, SF | 15 | ukjohn |
| 179. | Mark Redman – SP, Fla | 15 | chinch |
| 180. | Brett Myers – SP, Phi | 15 | kentx |
| 181. | Gil Meche – SP, Sea | 16 | kentx |
| 182. | Odalis Perez – SP, LA | 16 | chinch |
| 183. | Billy Koch – RP, ChA | 16 | ukjohn |
| 184. | Randy Winn – OF, Sea | 16 | abomb |
| 185. | Eric Milton – SP, Phi | 16 | mikcou |
| 186. | Melvin Mora – OF, Bal | 16 | Justise |
| 187. | Mike MacDougal – RP, KC | 16 | pkarr |
| 188. | Edgar Martinez – DH, Sea | 16 | jivedude |
| 189. | Jarrod Washburn – SP, Ana | 16 | rotodog |
| 190. | Brad Wilkerson – OF, Mon | 16 | nsulham |
| 191. | Chone Figgins – OF, Ana | 16 | grammy |
| 192. | Mike Cameron – OF, Sea | 16 | josh |
| 193. | Rafael Soriano – RP, Sea | 17 | josh |
| 194. | Edwin Jackson – SP, LA | 17 | grammy |
| 195. | D’Angelo Jiminez – 2B, Cin | 17 | nsulham |
| 196. | Jason Phillips – C/1B, NYN | 17 | rotodog |
| 197. | Cristian Guzman – SS, Min | 17 | jivedude |
| 198. | Erubiel Durazo – 1B, Oak | 17 | pkarr |
| 199. | Eric Young – 2B, SF | 17 | Justise |
| 200. | Hee Seop Choi – 1B, Fla | 17 | mikcou |
| 201. | Cliff Floyd – OF, NYN | 17 | abomb |
| 202. | Ken Griffey Jr. – OF, Cin | 17 | ukjohn |
| 203. | Shannon Stewart – OF, Min | 17 | chinch |
| 204. | Rocky Biddle – RP, Mon | 17 | kentx |
| 205. | Greg Myers – C, Tor | 18 | kentx |
| 206. | Jacque Jones – OF, Min | 18 | chinch |
| 207. | Kip Wells – SP, Pit | 18 | ukjohn |
| 208. | Byung-Hyun Kim – RP, Bos | 18 | abomb |
| 209. | Tim Wakefield – SP, Bos | 18 | mikcou |
| 210. | Kazuhisa Ishii – SP, LA | 18 | Justise |
| 211. | Milton Bradley – OF, Cle | 18 | pkarr |
| 212. | Steve Finley – OF, Ari | 18 | jivedude |
| 213. | Jerry Hairston Jr. – 2B, Bal | 18 | rotodog |
| 214. | Moises Alou – OF, ChN | 18 | nsulham |
| 215. | Khalil Greene – SS, SD | 18 | grammy |
| 216. | Rickie Weeks – 2B, Mil | 18 | josh |
| 217. | Jon Lieber – SP, NYA | 19 | josh |
| 218. | Miguel Batista – SP, Ari | 19 | grammy |
| 219. | Tom Glavine – SP, NYN | 19 | nsulham |
| 220. | Kelvim Escobar – SP, Ana | 19 | rotodog |
| 221. | Ted Lilly – SP, Tor | 19 | jivedude |
| 222. | Shea Hillenbrand – 1B/3B, Ari | 19 | pkarr |
| 223. | Joe Mauer – C, Min | 19 | Justise |
| 224. | Scott Williamson – RP, Bos | 19 | mikcou |
| 225. | Braden Looper – RP, Fla | 19 | abomb |
| 226. | Sean Casey – 1B, Cin | 19 | ukjohn |
| 227. | Lance Carter – RP, TB | 19 | chinch |
| 228. | Jose Valentin – SS, ChA | 19 | kentx |
| 229. | Luis Matos – OF, Bal | 20 | kentx |
| 230. | Julio Lugo – SS, TB | 20 | chinch |
| 231. | Jesse Crain – RP, Min | 20 | ukjohn |
| 232. | Adam Kennedy – 2B, Ana | 20 | abomb |
| 233. | Jeff Conine – 1B/OF, Fla | 20 | mikcou |
| 234. | Darren Dreifort – SP, LA | 20 | Justise |
| 235. | Brian Roberts – 2B, Bal | 20 | pkarr |
| 236. | Aquilino Lopez – RP, Tor | 20 | jivedude |
| 237. | Vinny Castilla – 3B, Atl | 20 | rotodog |
| 238. | Al Leiter – SP, NYN | 20 | nsulham |
| 239. | Ryan Wagner – RP, Cin | 20 | grammy |
| 240. | Adrian Beltre – 3B, LA | 20 | josh |
(Notes: 5×5 roto scoring was assumed for this mock. Players’ teams are current through the time of the draft, but may of course change during the offseason.)
Thanks once again to all our drafters!
subscribe
print version
